Puffy vs. Tuft & Needle Mattress

While all product recommendations are chosen independently, we may receive compensation for purchases made through our site. Learn more about our affiliate program here.

Puffy and Tuft & Needle are mattress companies that offer a variety of online mattresses and bedding products.

Puffy was founded in 2016 and is based out of Los Angeles. While the company hasn’t been around long, it focuses on “direct-to-door” mattress sales to keep its mattress prices affordable. Puffy launched with its flagship Puffy Mattress, then later released the Puffy Luxe Mattress. The company also offers bases and bedding, and has a limited bedroom furniture line.

Tuft & Needle was founded when two engineers wanted to change up the mattress industry and decided to see if consumers would be willing to purchase mattresses online. Tuft & Needle quickly became a success, then merged with Serta Simmons Bedding in 2018. The company launched with its T&N Original Mattress, but has since expanded to offer a luxury Mint Mattress, as well as bedding, pillows, and furniture. According to the company, 95 out of 100 people who try a Tuft & Needle mattress decide to keep their mattress.

To compare the Puffy vs Tuft & Needle mattresses, we will focus on the flagship mattresses offered by each company.

Puffy Mattress vs. Tuft & Needle Mattress – Which One Should You Buy?

Even with all of the above factors outlined, it can still be difficult to look at these two mattresses and decide which is right for you. We’ve created the below list highlighting the ways that these mattresses are different so that you can better identify the benefits that each mattress provides. Consider your preferences, sleep habits, and needs when reading this list to help you choose the right mattress.

Buy the Puffy if...

1. Need excellent motion isolation

The Puffy Mattress has excellent motion isolation properties. If you’re worried about you or your partner being woken up in the night, this mattress can help you to sleep, undisturbed.

2. Want a cover that won’t stain

The Puffy Mattress comes with a stain-resistant cover so you can wipe up stains quickly and easily. It’s also removable for seasonal deep-cleaning.

3. Want a long-term warranty

While the Tuft & Needle mattress only offers a 10-year warranty, Puffy’s lifetime warranty is hard to beat (assuming you have the mattress for more than 10 years). Under this warranty, Puffy will replace any mattress that has defects in its craftsmanship or construction.

 

Buy the Tuft & Needle if...

1. Need pressure relief with support

The T&N Adaptive® Foam in this mattress offers pressure relief paired with support. While you’ll sink into the mattress a bit, you won’t feel like you can’t move around or get out of bed.

2. Want a little bounce

The Tuft & Needle Mattress has a little more bounce than a traditional memory foam mattress. This can make a difference when shifting around at night or getting out of bed, and reduces the sinking, compression sensation common in traditional memory foam.

3. Want white glove delivery

If you don’t want to deal with getting rid of your old mattress, Tuft & Needle will take care of that for you with their white glove delivery. Puffy does not offer a white glove delivery option, so disposing of your old mattress is up to you.

 

Tuft & Needle Bed

Both the Puffy and Tuft & Needle mattresses offer many of the benefits of memory foam mattresses, such as reduced pressure points and a comfortable, contouring surface. These mattresses can also both be paired with traditional and adjustable bed bases, allowing you to find that perfect comfortable sleep position.

While the mattresses are similar in price, there are also some differences in their construction. The Tuft & Needle Mattress combines some of the best benefits of latex, such as its resilience and bounce, with the properties of memory foam. This gives it a slight edge over the Puffy Mattress, which is made of several different memory foam layers.

These mattresses both check all of the important boxes in terms of performance, such as temperature regulation, pressure relief, and contouring with support. In comparing the Tuft & Needle vs Puffy mattress, the differences really come down to small factors like edge support and resilience. Choosing the right mattress for you will really come down to the small details and your personal thoughts on the features you want to see in your ideal mattress.

Mattress Construction Comparison

Puffy

The Puffy Mattress is built with three individual layers. The 6” Firm Core Support base layer adds durability and allows the mattress to be used on any stable surface. The 2” ClimateComfort layer helps to neutralize temperature and does not expand or contract in fluctuating temperatures. This makes for a consistent feeling throughout the year. That layer is topped by the 2” Cooling Cloud Foam layer, which contours to your body and eliminates pressure points.

The Puffy Cloud Cover and Cloud Foam are made in the United States. Puffy also designs, assembles, and sews its mattresses in the United States. Creating the mattress entirely within the country saves unnecessary shipping expenses. It also offers valuable environmental benefits, since less fuel is consumed and emissions are limited because of the reduced shipping needs.

Puffy mattress layers construction

Tuft & Needle

Some mattresses feature many layers of foams, but the Tuft & Needle Mattress takes a different approach. This mattress’s dual-layer construction includes just two layers of foam. The support layer is made of high-quality foam to create a base that is topped by the T&N Adaptive® Foam. This T&N Adaptive® Foam features qualities of both memory foam and latex, allowing it to contour to the shape of your body while still being durable and resilient. Because the mattress consists of just two layers, it promotes airflow for a cooler temperature while also reducing the mattress’ price. All Tuft & Needle mattresses are completed in a Southern California factory and they’re made of foam created in the United States and fabric from a mill in the Carolinas.

Tuft & Needle Mattress Construction

Firmness Comparison

Firmness varies from mattress to mattress, and you’ll need to find a mattress that has the right firmness for your personal preferences and needs in order to be comfortable.

The firmness of a mattress refers to how the mattress feels when you lie down on it. When you lie on a softer mattress, you may feel as if you’re sinking down into it, whereas a firmer mattress doesn’t have that same amount of give, so it will feel like you’re sleeping more on top of the mattress. A mattress’ firmness is affected by the types of materials used and how they’re arranged into different layers.

There isn’t one perfect mattress firmness and everyone develops their own personal preferences for the type of firmness that they find most comfortable. People with chronic pain and those who are side sleepers often prefer softer mattresses because they can help to relieve pressure. Lightweight sleepers sometimes find a softer mattress more comfortable, while heavier sleepers may feel more supported by a firmer mattress.

Mattresses with different firmness levels tend to have different qualities. While it can feel great to sink down into a soft mattress, this position can increase the amount of your body that is in contact with the mattress, making you feel warmer at night. Firmer mattresses may sleep cooler, though the different materials used in a mattress will also affect its temperature. If you frequently reposition yourself at night, you may find it’s easier to move around in a firmer mattress than it is in a softer mattress. Ultimately, it’s best to try out a variety of mattresses to determine just what you prefer.

The Puffy Mattress is a medium firmness, which ranks at 5-5.5 on the firmness scale. Its Cooling Cloud layer gently conforms to your body, eliminating pressure points while still leaving you with a feeling of cradling support. Its blend of softness and support is ideal for side sleepers, since it alleviates the typical issue of pressure points forming on the shoulders and hips. However, this mattress also offers a blend of support and softness that makes it a comfortable choice for people who sleep on their backs. While the mattress cradles you in comfort, it’s still firm enough so that you don’t sink down too deeply.

While Tuft & Needle doesn’t define a specific firmness for their mattress, expect the mattress to feel somewhere between a soft and a medium firmness. The T&N Adaptive® Foam is designed to react in accordance with the amount of weight that’s placed on it; the mattress will push back harder against someone who is heavier than it will with a lighter sleeper. This property means that while the sleep surface feels soft, it is never so soft that you feel unsupported, and you won’t feel that you’re sinking down too deeply into the mattress. The T&N Adaptive® Foam is a unique material that combines the pressure relief of memory foam and the bounce of latex, giving this mattress a firmer feel than you would find in a typical mattress made only of memory foam.

Sleep Experience

When comparing the Tuft & Needle vs. Puffy Mattress, you’ll need to consider a number of different sleep experience elements to get a sense of all of the qualities that each mattress offers. Elements such as temperature control, edge support, and motion transfer can affect the quality of sleep that you’ll enjoy on a mattress, and you may personally value some of these sleep experience elements more than others. Understanding these nuances of how each mattress will feel at night can help you to determine which mattress is right for you.

Temperature Control

Different materials can help to make a mattress feel cooler all night long. Some materials naturally feel cool to the touch, while a mattress designed to be highly breathable can cool itself down, rather than allowing heat to build up while you sleep. If you often wake up feeling too warm, a mattress that sleeps cool can help you to fall back to sleep.

The Puffy Mattress’ Cooling Cloud layer draws heat out of the mattress. This layer is infused with a Cloud Gel layer which maintains an optimal temperature, keeping you comfortable during the night. The Cooling Cloud layer is paired with a ClimateComfort layer which stabilizes the mattress’ temperature and prevents sudden temperature swings. In the winter, this layer offers a subtle warming effect, then offers subtle cooling properties during the hot summer months.

The Tuft & Needle Mattress also offers excellent temperature control. Heat wicking gel and graphite in the T&N Adaptive® Foam layer help to keep the mattress cool, while the mattress’ hybrid design maximizes airflow. The mattress is topped with a breathable cover.

Motion Transfer

If you sleep with a partner, the motion transfer properties of a mattress can affect the quality of sleep that you both get. When a mattress controls motion transfer well, you can shift around or get out of bed at night without disturbing your partner. If you or a partner get up or go to bed at different times, then a mattress that controls motion transfer can help you to both sleep better.

The Puffy Mattress offers slightly better motion transfer prevention than you’ll find in the Tuft & Needle Mattress. Because the Cooling Cloud Foam layer offers a soft surface that helps to minimize pressure points, it can also absorb motion. The Tuft & Needle mattress does help to minimize motion transfer, but the T&N Adaptive® Foam does have some of the bounce that you’d find in a latex mattress. This slight bounce allows slightly more motion transfer than the Puffy Mattress.

Responsiveness

Mattresses need to be able to adjust to changes in pressure to keep you comfortable and supported; this is called responsiveness. A mattress that quickly responds to pressure changes can quickly accommodate different sleeping positions. A highly responsive mattress that quickly accommodates pressure changes can feel a little bouncy. On the other end of the spectrum, a mattress that is slower to respond and that has less responsiveness will let you sink down into it. As you shift around, the mattress may stay compressed and be slow to respond to your new position.

The Puffy Mattress has average responsiveness. The Firm Core Support Layer promotes an ideal spinal alignment yet also relieves pressure points, but its Cooling Cloud layer is made of visco polyurethane foam, which is slow to respond to pressure.

The Tuft & Needle Mattress is a very responsive mattress, thanks to the unique construction of the T&N Adaptive® Foam. This foam contours like memory foam, but it’s imbued with the bounce and resiliency of latex which makes it much faster to respond to weight than traditional memory foam. As you put more weight on the mattress, it responds accordingly. This design allows the mattress to create a soft yet supportive surface that can accommodate sleepers of any size or weight.

Resilience and Bounce

A mattress that lacks bounce can make it difficult to change positions or to get out of bed at night. But if your mattress is too bouncy, it can bounce too much when you shift around, which can cause motion to transfer, waking up your partner. Some bounce, also called resiliency, is important since your mattress needs to be able to rebound after pressure is removed. A lack of resiliency can lead to mattresses compressing over time. This is what causes the sagging that you’ll see in some lower-quality memory foam mattresses.

The Tuft & Needle Mattress has more bounce and resiliency than the Puffy Mattress, due to its T&N Adaptive® Foam. This foam incorporates the bounce and resiliency of latex. Whereas memory foam has limited resiliency and almost no bounce, the T&N Adaptive® Foam still has the contouring properties of memory foam but with the added benefit of resiliency and bounce.

Because the Puffy Mattress’ Cooling Cloud layer is made of visco polyurethane foam, a type of memory foam, it lacks the prompt rebound that the Tuft & Needle’s latex properties provide.

Edge Support

If you use a memory foam mattress for years, you may notice that its edges start to sag, especially in the areas where you get in and out of bed. Memory foam can compress over time if not properly supported, and these high-traffic edge areas can sag. This can make it more difficult to get into and out of bed and reduces the amount of the area available as a sleeping surface. To prevent this, mattresses can be reinforced with additional materials to support the edges from within. These supports may be coils or additional layers of dense foam within the mattress.

Neither of these mattresses have features that promote increased edge support. However, the Tuft & Needle Mattress is slightly more durable than the Puffy Mattress because the latex properties of the T&N Adaptive® Foam make the foam more resilient than the Puffy Mattress. If you are particularly concerned about this, you may want to consider choosing an innerspring or a latex mattress instead.

Off-gassing and Smell

After unpacking a mattress, you may notice a plastic-like or chemical-like odor in your room. This odor occurs through a process called off-gassing, where the unwrapped mattress releases volatile organic compounds (VOCs) from its foam into the air. Most mattresses undergo some off-gassing, but some mattresses result in much stronger and longer-lasting smells than others. If you purchase a mattress with strong off-gassing, you may need to air out your room for a few days before you’re able to use the mattress comfortably.

Both of these mattresses have minimal off-gassing. The Puffy Mattress will have a slight smell during the first few days, but that smell quickly dissipates. This mattress has been made with foams that are CertiPUR-US® certified to contain no mercury, lead, formaldehyde, or other harmful compounds.

The Tuft & Needle Mattress has low off-gassing levels, and the foam used in the mattress has low levels of VOCs. The foam is CertiPUR-US® and GREENGUARD Gold certified, a testament to the fact that it contains no harmful chemicals and has been tested to have low off-gassing levels.

Shipping, Trial, Warranty, and Returns

The cost of a mattress itself is only one consideration when deciding which mattress you should purchase. You’ll need to consider other expenses, including delivery fees, the cost of removing your old mattress, and potential fees you’ll face when returning a mattress that you don’t want. To compare Puffy vs. Tuft & Needle mattresses, you should consider these factors as well as the different sleep trials and mattress warranties that each company offers.

Puffy Tuft & Needle
Delivery fee Free in the U.S. Free
How is it shipped? FedEx Ground, bed-in-a-box Bed-in-a-box
Old mattress removal? No No
Sleep trial length 101 nights 100 nights
Return cost and process Call or email during the trial to request a return. Puffy will pick up and donate the mattress to charity. No cost; company picks up
Warranty length Lifetime warranty 10 years

Prices, Sizes, and Value

The price of different mattresses vary significantly, and while you shouldn’t make a purchase decision based on price alone, your new mattress purchase does need to fit within your budget. Sometimes certain mattresses are worth splurging for, but you’ll need to decide if you can truly afford a mattress that’s a bit outside of your budget.

Puffy
Tuft & Needle
Mattress Size Price
Twin $795
Twin XL $825
Full $995
Queen $1,150
King $1,350
California King $1,350
Mattress Size Price
Twin $350
Twin XL $395
Full $495
Queen $595
King $750
California King $750

When comparing the Tuft & Needle vs Puffy mattresses, the mattresses are fairly close in price, with the Puffy Mattress costing just a bit more than the Tuft & Needle Mattress. If you think back to the sleep experience factors highlighted above, the Tuft & Needle Mattress came out ahead in a few areas, including edge support and resiliency. In terms of other qualities, like heat control, the mattresses are pretty closely matched in terms of overall value. Puffy does offer a lifetime warranty on its mattress, whereas Tuft & Needle only offers a 10-year warranty.

All things considered, the Tuft & Needle Mattress offers nearly all of the same benefits of the Puffy Mattress (and some additional benefits), making its lower price even more appealing.