Beautyrest Black Mattress Review

While all product recommendations are chosen independently, we may receive compensation for purchases made through our site. Learn more about our affiliate program here.

Simmons enjoys a strong reputation in the mattress industry. While the name has changed over the years, the foundations of the Simmons company date back to 1871. Beautyrest, Simmons’s flagship brand, launched in 1925.

Simmons has two main mattress brands: Beautyrest and BeautySleep. Within the Beautyrest brand, there are multiple mattress collections, including Beautyrest Black, Beautyrest Platinum, Beautyrest Silver, Beautyrest Recharge, Beautyrest Exclusive, and Beautyrest Hybrid. Here we will focus exclusively on the Beautyrest Black collection mattresses currently available through the Beautyrest website. Other mattress options in the Beautyrest Black Collection may be available through other vendors.

The Beautyrest website has three mattress options in the Black collection: Original, Cooling, and Cooling+Comfort.

  • Original: The Original mattress is constructed using four layers of comfort foam, which include half an inch of Plush Comfort Foam, one inch of Medium Comfort Foam, one and a half inches of Energy Foam, and half an inch of Beautyrest Gel Memory Foam. The support layer includes T3 Pocketed Coil® Technology and BeautyEdge®.
  • Cooling: Like the Original mattress, the Cooling mattress uses four layers of comfort foam. However, these layers are constructed differently. The layers include half an inch of Plush Comfort Foam, one inch of Medium Comfort Foam, one inch of RightTemp™ Memory Foam, and one inch of Beautyrest Gel Memory Foam. The support system also uses Beautyrest’s T3 Pocketed Coil® Technology and BeautyEdge®.
  • Cooling+Comfort: The Cooling+Comfort mattress uses five layers of comfort foam: three-quarters of an inch of GelTouch® Foam, one inch of Medium Comfort Foam, two inches of Beautyrest Gel Memory Foam, one inch of RightTemp™ Memory Foam, and one inch of Medium Comfort Foam. Like the Original and the Cooling mattresses, the support system uses Beautyrest’s T3 Pocketed Coil® Technology and BeautyEdge®.

Read on for a full review of the Beautyrest Black collection. We’ll share key information about pricing, performance, and more that may help you decide if a Beautyrest Black mattress is right for you, and, if so, which Beautyrest Black mattress may best suit your needs.

In-depth Beautyrest Black Mattress Review

Beautyrest Black Sizing and Pricing

Dimensions and pricing for each mattress and mattress size in the Beautyrest Black collection are detailed below. This collection includes most standard mattress sizes. However, it does not currently include Twin mattresses, though Twin XL mattresses are available.

Dimensions Original Black Cooling Cooling + Comfort
Twin XL

Original/Cooling: 38" x 79.5" x 13"

Cooling+Comfort: 38" x 79.5" x 15"

$1,699 $2,199 $2,399
Full

Original/Cooling: 53" x 74.5" x 13"

Cooling+Comfort: 53" x 74.5" x 15"

$1,979 $2,479 $2,679
Queen

Original/Cooling: 60" x 79.5" x 13"

Cooling+Comfort: 60" x 79.5" x 15"

$2,099 $2,699 $2,899
King

Original/Cooling: 76" x 79.5" x 13"

Cooling+Comfort: 76" x 79.5" x 15"

$2,599 $3,399 $3,599
California King

Original/Cooling: 72" x 83.5" x 13"

Cooling+Comfort: 72" x 83.5" x 15"

$2,599 $3,399 $3,599
Firmness

Mattress firmness is a subjective measurement related to comfort. It is typically referred to on a scale of 1 to 10, with 1 being extremely soft and 10 being extremely firm.

The Original mattress and the Cooling mattress are Medium. We would rank them around a 6 on the firmness scale. Beautyrest calls the Cooling+Comfort mattress’s firmness “plush pillow top,” which we would consider Medium Soft, or approximately 4 on the firmness scale.

Availability

The Original, Cooling, and Cooling+Comfort mattresses are available online through the Beautyrest website. Beautyrest ships within the contiguous United States. Other mattresses in the Beautyrest Black collection are widely available through third-party retailers, including select mattress stores, furniture stores, and department stores.

Construction

The Original, Cooling, and Cool+Comfort mattresses all have support layers with T3 Pocketed Coil® Technology and BeautyEdge®. The cover of each mattress uses fabric that is made to feel cool to the touch. The construction of the comfort layers is the main factor that differentiates between the mattress designs.

  • Original: The Original mattress’s comfort system includes four distinct layers: half an inch of Plush Comfort Foam, one inch of Medium Comfort Foam, one and a half inches of Energy Foam, and half an inch of Beautyrest Gel Memory Foam.
  • Cooling: The comfort layers of the Cooling mattress include half an inch of Plush Comfort Foam, one inch of Medium Comfort Foam, one inch of RightTemp™ Memory Foam, and one inch of Beautyrest Gel Memory Foam.
  • Cooling+Comfort: The Cooling+Comfort mattress’s comfort system includes five layers: three-quarters of an inch of GelTouch® Foam, one inch of Medium Comfort Foam, two inches of Beautyrest Gel Memory Foam, one inch of RightTemp™ Memory Foam, and one inch of Medium Comfort Foam.

 

Shipping

Beautyrest ships within the contiguous United States with free White Glove Delivery. After placing an order, you will receive an email detailing how to schedule a delivery through Beautyrest’s shipping partner XPO Logistics. Typical delivery hours available are between 7am-7pm, Monday through Saturday. On that date, the delivery partner will set up your new mattress and remove the packaging.

A customer or adult must be present at the scheduled time and address to receive the mattress. If no adult is present, the mattress may be left with a secure receiving authority. The delivery partner can also remove your old mattress if you wish.

Sleep Trial

If you purchase through the Beautyrest website, Beautyrest offers a 100-night sleep trial period. If you choose to return your Beautyrest Black mattress during that time, you can receive a full refund of the purchase price.

Reach out to Beautyrest’s support email to schedule a return. They will remove the mattress at no charge to you. Beautyrest only allows for one return and refund per household per year.

Warranty

Beautyrest offers a 10-year limited warranty on the Black mattress collection, beginning on the date of purchase. Said warranty covers defects in manufacturing and materials of the mattress.

If a mattress is deemed defective and covered under warranty, Beautyrest will provide a replacement of the product. If a mattress is discontinued, Beautyrest will supply a similar product in terms of quality and value. Mattresses must be used in accordance with Beautyrest’s standards for proper support and proper care in order to qualify for a claim.

Warranty valid for the original purchaser of the mattress and is not transferable. Valid claims cannot be made outside of the US, Puerto Rico, or US Virgin Islands. Beautyrest will require a copy of the original bill of sale to validate the purchase date. Original mattress labels will also be required.

Beautyrest Black Mattress Performance

Motion Isolation

The Original, Cooling, and Cooling+Comfort mattresses all use multiple layers of foam in their comfort systems. These foam layers isolate motion well. The Original and Cooling mattresses use four layers of foam, while the Cooling+Comfort mattress uses five layers of foam. While the innerspring layer still transfers some motion, the coils are pocketed to reduce the transfer of motion across the support layer.

We would expect the Cooling+Comfort mattress to isolate motion better than the Original and the Cooling mattresses because it is softer and uses a thicker comfort system.

Edge Support

All three mattresses have Beautyrest’s BeautyEdge® for extra edge support. This foam encasement wraps around the innerspring layer to reinforce the edge of the bed. While the foam in the top layers may compress when you near the edge of the bed, this edge support system prevents excessive sinking, making it easier to sit or sleep near the perimeter of the bed.

Heat Retention

The memory foam in the Original, Cooling, and Cooling+Comfort mattresses may trap some heat. However, each mattress has cooling features to reduce heat retention, so they sleep cooler than many memory foam mattresses.

All three mattresses have covers that are cool to the touch. Their innerspring support layers allow greater airflow than solid foam support layers. The Original mattress’s BlackICE 4.0 system was developed for cooler sleeping. The Cooling mattress uses the same system, but it also incorporates RightTemp™ Memory Foam for additional cooling. The Cooling+Comfort mattress builds on the cooling properties of the Original and Cooling mattresses and adds GelTouch® Foam. This foam is fabricated for extra cooling airflow.

The extra cooling features in the Cooling and the Cooling+Comfort mattresses may make them sleep cooler than the Original mattress.

Off-Gassing

Foam often emits an initial odor. The Beautyrest Black collection uses foam in the comfort layers, so Beautyrest Black mattresses may let off a slight odor at first. This odor is not harmful, however, and it should air out within a couple of days if left in a well-ventilated area.

Support

The Beautyrest Black collection’s combination of memory foam comfort layers and coils can encourage better spinal alignment.

The foam comfort layers contour to the body by compressing in response to body heat and weight. The innerspring layer gives deeper contouring for the heavier, wider parts of your body. Since the coils are individually-wrapped, they can move independently of each other for more precise support.

Conforming

The conforming capabilities of the Beautyrest Black collection are greater than many mattresses. The Original, Cooling, and Cooling+Comfort mattresses all have comfort layers that include memory foam, which is known for its exceptional conforming. The innerspring layers pocketed coils move independently of each other for additional deep contouring.

The Cooling+Comfort mattress conforms more noticeably because it is softer and has a thicker comfort layer.

Durability

Based on materials, construction, and customer reviews, we would expect the Original, Cooling, and Cooling+Comfort mattresses to have a similar lifespan to many other innerspring mattresses, likely between 5 and 6 years.

Sex

The Beautyrest Black mattress models may be more conducive to sexual activity than most all-foam mattresses, but they are unlikely to perform as well in this category as innerspring and latex mattresses.

The innerspring coils give the Beautyrest Black mattresses bounce, which many couples find beneficial for sex. The conforming of the memory foam comfort layers, however, may impede movement across the surface of the bed. This effect may be more pronounced in the Cooling+Comfort mattress due to its softness and thicker comfort layers.

Noise

The Beautyrest Black mattress models are unlikely to be as quiet as most all-foam mattresses because the innerspring layer may occasionally squeak, pop, or clunk. However, the coils are individually-wrapped, which prevents some of the noise often associated with innerspring mattresses. While they are not completely silent, the Beautyrest Black mattresses will likely be quiet enough to satisfy most sleepers.

How Do Customers Rate the Beautyrest Black Mattress?

Website Reviews
Beautyrest.com 4.1/5 (22 reviews)
Google Shopping N/A
Consumer Reports N/A
Amazon N/A

What Type of Sleeper Is Well Suited to a Beautyrest Black Mattress?

Side Sleepers: Mattresses in the Black collection pair foam comfort layers and innerspring support layers, which can relieve the pressure points side sleepers tend to experience. The comfort layers conform to the unique shape of each sleeper’s body, while the individually-pocketed coils contour more deeply. Side sleepers with particularly sharp pressure points may favor the extra softness and conforming of the Cooling+Comfort mattress.

Back Sleepers: Back sleepers generally benefit from a mattress that supports the spine while preventing heavier parts of the body, like the hips, from sinking in excessively. The Black collection’s contouring and conforming can provide the necessary spinal support. The firmness and thinner comfort layers in the Original and the Cooling mattresses may give them an edge over the Cooling+Comfort mattress when it comes to supporting back sleepers.

Stomach Sleepers: Stomach sleepers usually need a mattress that prevents their midsections from sinking in too much. Excessive sinking of the midsection can put the spine out of alignment, creating pain and pressure. The Original and Cooling models may provide an appropriate amount of support and softness for most stomach sleepers. However, they may be slightly too soft for stomach sleepers over 230 pounds and slightly too firm for stomach sleepers who weigh under 130 pounds. Stomach sleepers under 130 pounds may prefer the added softness of the Cooling+Comfort model.

Original and Cooling Model
Below Average Weight (under 130 lbs) Average Weight (130-230 lbs) Above Average Weight (above 230 lbs)
Side Sleepers Good Good Good
Back Sleepers Good Very Good Good
Stomach Sleepers Fair Good Fair
Cooling+Comfort Model
Below Average Weight (under 130 lbs) Average Weight (130-230 lbs) Above Average Weight (above 230 lbs)
Side Sleepers Very Good Very Good Good
Back Sleepers Good Good Fair
Stomach Sleepers Very Good Good Good

About Simmons Beautyrest

Customer Service: Beautyrest customers generally rate the customer service team as fair.

Reputation: Simmons Beautyrest has a long-established reputation as a major mattress company.

BBB Rating: Simmons Bedding Co. receives a B rating from the Better Business Bureau.

Years in Business: Simmons has been in business since 1871. Beautyrest was introduced in 1925.

Physical Stores: Beautyrest mattresses are widely available in mattress stores, furniture stores, and department stores. However, the Original Black, Cooling, and Cooling+Comfort mattresses are sold direct-to-consumers through the Beautyrest website.

Contact Information: [email protected], 1-877-298-4955, https://www.Beautyrest.com

Our Verdict

Simmons is a very well-known company with a long history in the mattress industry. The Beautyrest brand is prominent and widely available. Beautyrest’s Black collection is considered a luxury line, and many of its features will have mass appeal.

The Original, Cooling, and Cooling+Comfort mattresses have comfort layers constructed of multiple layers of foam, including memory foam, which conform to the body. All three mattresses have cooling features that prevent much of the heat retention often associated with memory foam. The cooling features in the Cooling and Cooling+Comfort mattress are particularly notable, so they may appeal to those who tend to sleep hot. An innerspring layer gives each mattress additional breathability, support, and bounce.

These three mattresses are considered luxury mattresses, and they have the accompanying luxury price point. Because of this, they are best for customers with higher budgets. You can decide if one of these Beautyrest Black mattresses is right for you with a 100-night sleep trial. A 10-year limited warranty may also give you added peace of mind.

Here’s how we rate the Beautyrest Black mattresses on a scale of 1 (worst) to 10 (best):

8.6
Material Quality
8.3 / 10
Support
9.1 / 10
Temperature Regulation
9.0 / 10
Off-Gassing
8.7 / 10
Suitability for Sex
8.5 / 10
Trial period
8.8 / 10
Warranty
8.4 / 10
Company Reputation
8.8 / 10
Value for the Money
7.4 / 10

Pros

-Cooling features in the Original, Cooling, and Cooling+comfort models reduce the potential for heat retention
-Owners often note solid conforming, support, motion isolation, and edge support from mattresses in the Black collection
-The Beautyrest brand is well-established
-Free White Glove Delivery and old mattress removal

Cons

-Some customers note that their mattresses from the Black collection have a below-average lifespan
-More expensive than most other mattresses
-Specifications on the density of the foams are not publically available